top of page
  • Writer's pictureRobert Spicer

Derby crushing death: three companies fined

Crushing death: three companies fined

Health and Safety Executive v Punchards Haulage Limited, VTK Structures Ltd and Hanson Packed Products Limited (2015) Derby Crown Court, December 10

Three companies have been fined following the death of a worker by crushing.

Significant points of the case

  • In January 2011 Travis Hale, a driver employed by Punchards, went to Hanson’s premises in Derby to collect a trailer loaded with four concrete panels. The panels had been designed by VTK and manufactured by Hanson. The load was secured to the trailer with three vehicle straps supplied by Punchards.

  • Hale was asked to check his load. He was joined by employees of VTK who advised him to fit more straps. When he undid a strap, a panel weighing one and half tons fell onto him, causing fatal crushing injuries.

  • The number of straps were not adequate to secure the load safely for transport. All three companies should have cooperated to ensure that a safer means of securing concrete panels on the trailer were used.

Punchards Hauling Limited was fined £140,000 plus £37,000 costs for a breach of section 2, HSW Act, for failing to ensure the health and safety of employees.

VTK Structures Limited was fined £140,000 plus £37,000 under section 3, HSW Act, for failing to ensure the health and safety of non-employees.

Hanson Packed Products Limited was fined £80,000 plus £37,000 costs under regulation 3, Management of Health and Safety At Work Regulations 1999, for failing to carry out a suitable and sufficient risk assessment.

Recent Posts

See All


Limitation Case TVZ v Manchester City Football Club Ltd [2022] EWHC 7, Hugh Court Facts Eight men who had been sexually abused by a football coach in the 1980s claimed compensation in negligence fro

Crown immunity and the rule of law (3)

Civil proceedings Until 1948 the Crown could not be made a party to a civil action. This was an offshoot of the principle of sovereign immunity. The Crown Proceedings Act 1947 changed this rule. The C

Crown immunity and the rule of law (2)

Recent examples In June 2018 prison officers were taking part in a petrol bomb training exercise. This was part of an eight-day commanders course at the National Tactical Response Group training facil


Post: Blog2_Post
bottom of page