• Robert Spicer

Disability discrimination and dismissal


Dismissal tainted by discrimination

Case P2CG v Davis (2021) Morning Star, November 9, EAT

Facts D was employed by P as a business development director. In 2015 the company had three other directors: P, K and R. Following a performance meeting with the three other directors in June 2016, D was issued with a written warning for unsatisfactory performance and was told that if this did not improve within six weeks, further disciplinary action would be considered, including dismissal. In July 2016 D was diagnosed with type one diabetes. In August 2016 he was dismissed for poor performance. D claimed direct discrimination, discrimination arising from disability, indirect discrimination, failure to comply with the duty to make reasonable adjustments and harassment related to his disability. The employment tribunal (ET) found that D’s disability had significantly influenced the decision to dismiss him. The burden of proof then shifted to the three directors to prove that the dismissal was not because of his disability. They had not discharged this burden and the claims of direct discrimination were upheld. The directors appealed to the EAT, arguing that the tribunal had failed to properly apply the non-discriminatory reasons for the dismissal.

Decision 1. The appeal was dismissed.

2. D had been dismissed because his disability meant that his performance was less likely to improve.

3. As a matter of principle, a dismissal could be on legitimate performance grounds but materially tainted by discrimination.

2 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

In 2018 the UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights reported that in the UK 14 million people, a fifth of the population, live in poverty. Four million of them are more than 50 per c

DISABILITY DISCRIMINATION Risk to health Secondment opportunity Case Judd v Cabinet Office EA-2020-000468-AT Facts J, a disabled person employed by CO, successfully applied for secondment in Montenegr

SEX DISCRIMINATION Interim relief Human rights Case Steer v Stormsure Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 887, Court of Appeal Facts S was employed by S Ltd for four months. She alleged that her dismissal amounted to